Quantcast

20 August 2007

Nestle not quite everyone's cup.


Australia's coffee industry is getting itself into a froth at international ffood company Nestle's attempts to trademark images of coffee in a coffee mug.

According to IP Australia, Nestle's application is for two images of coffee - a cup of black coffee in a white cup viewed from above and a red coffee mug, viewed from the front.

"We were convinced in the end and we were convinced by evidence of use that the company was able to supply, which demonstrated they had used that particular image repeatedly over a number of years, and that people in fact recognised it and associated it with their goods and services," the registrar for trademarks in Australia Ruth Mackie is reported to have said.

According to Mackie the image is visibly distinctive. In both cases, we assume the image is not generic as has been claimed by the Australian Coffee Association but is associated with Nestle's logo as in the Blend 43 pic above.

The normal approval process used by IP Australia involves an opposition period of three months, a review and then a final ruling made by the office.

What's most interesting is that opponents of the move seemed to have fogetten that Nestle has also been successful in registering the word "Decaf" in Australia without the level of opposition this latest application is enjoying.

A similar image dispute has opened between car maker Toyota and Qantas' Jetstar over the "jumping people" image. Toyota's claims copyright of the image through its long association with the O, What a Feeling campaign developed by Saatchi and Saatchi but there is no evidence that any trademark application has been lodgeed by Toyota or Jetstar for the image.

DIFFUSION assumes that any claim Toyota would make would rest on fair use evidence.

No comments: